
A bowl of mashed potatoes topped with melting butter and chopped chives. Photo: Jon Sullivan, Wikimedia Commons (public domain).
BuzzFeed writer Micah Siva cooked four celebrity mashed potato recipes side by side, and scored each one out of five for taste, texture, richness and ease. This post names all four recipes, explains how each one turned out, and reveals the clear winner. The scores below are Micah's, as reported by BuzzFeed.
The winner: Julia Child's Mashed Potatoes — 4.5/5. Julia Child's recipe was the clear winner. It was the only one to score 5 out of 5 for taste, and it also scored 5 out of 5 for richness. Thick, rich and super fluffy, with a deep garlic flavour, it holds its shape so gravy sits on top instead of turning it soupy. It was the most work of the four, but Micah said she would happily eat it with every meal.
The four recipes, ranked from last to first
- Martha Stewart — Perfect Mashed Potatoes — 3/5
- Ina Garten — Garlic Mashed Potatoes — 3.5/5
- Snoop Dogg — Mayo Mash — 4/5
- Julia Child — Mashed Potatoes — 4.5/5 — the winner
4th place: Martha Stewart's Perfect Mashed Potatoes — 3/5
Scores: Taste 3/5, Texture 2/5, Richness 4/5, Ease 3/5.
What it is: Martha Stewart's classic mashed potatoes, which she calls creamy and delicious. The recipe uses a stand mixer to whip the potatoes, and includes a hint of nutmeg.
How it turned out: the least impressive of the four. The flavour was there, but the texture was off — quite a few chunks of potato were left in the mix, and despite several minutes of whipping, the potatoes stayed loose and watery. Micah also found the nutmeg off-putting in mashed potatoes. As she put it, these were not the best mashed potatoes, but also not the worst.
3rd place: Ina Garten's Garlic Mashed Potatoes — 3.5/5
Scores: Taste 4/5, Texture 3/5, Richness 3/5, Ease 4/5.
What it is: Ina Garten's garlic mashed potatoes, made by slowly cooking garlic in olive oil — a garlic confit — and mashing it through the potatoes. Olive oil is used instead of butter, which gives the mash a rich yellow colour and a lighter feel.
How it turned out: good, but surprisingly subtle. The garlic flavour was so mellow that Micah almost could not taste it at all, and the mash was not as creamy as she would have liked. It was one of the easiest recipes to make, but it did not have the richness of the top two.
2nd place: Snoop Dogg's Mayo Mash — 4/5
Scores: Taste 4/5, Texture 3/5, Richness 5/5, Ease 4/5.
What it is: Snoop Dogg's mashed potatoes, made with cream, butter and mayonnaise, and mashed with a potato masher.
How it turned out: the richest dish of the four, and a surprise hit. It came out fluffy and smooth, with a slight eggy tang from the mayonnaise. It matched Julia Child's recipe for richness, but its taste and texture did not quite reach the same level, so it finished second.
1st place: Julia Child's Mashed Potatoes — 4.5/5 — the winner
Scores: Taste 5/5, Texture 4/5, Richness 5/5, Ease 3/5.
What it is: Julia Child's mashed potatoes, made from Russet potatoes with a garlic-butter bechamel. A flour roux is cooked with warmed milk, garlic butter and parsley, then folded through the mashed potatoes.
How it turned out: the best by a clear margin. Super fluffy, with a deep garlic flavour, thick and rich, and sturdy enough to hold its shape under gravy. It was the most labour-intensive recipe of the four, but that extra work paid off. It was the only recipe to earn a perfect score for taste, and that is why Julia Child's mashed potatoes won.
Why Julia Child won
Julia Child won on taste. Hers was the only recipe to score 5 out of 5 for taste, and it matched Snoop Dogg's for richness at 5 out of 5, while also holding its shape better for gravy. Snoop Dogg's Mayo Mash was the easiest of the top two and just as rich, but Julia's fluffy texture and deep garlic flavour gave her the clear win.
More from StarBuzz Daily: For another celebrity taste test, read We tried 7 celebrity pasta recipes and found 1 favorite, and for celebrity news beyond food, see the Top 5 Celebrity Brand Collabs You Need to Know Now.
Frequently asked questions
Whose mashed potato recipe won? Julia Child's Mashed Potatoes, with an overall score of 4.5 out of 5 — the clear winner.
Which four recipes were tested? Julia Child's Mashed Potatoes, Snoop Dogg's Mayo Mash, Ina Garten's Garlic Mashed Potatoes, and Martha Stewart's Perfect Mashed Potatoes.
Which recipe is the easiest to make? Ina Garten's Garlic Mashed Potatoes and Snoop Dogg's Mayo Mash were the easiest, both scoring 4 out of 5 for ease.
Which recipe is the richest? Snoop Dogg's Mayo Mash and Julia Child's Mashed Potatoes both scored 5 out of 5 for richness.
Who did the taste test? BuzzFeed writer Micah Siva tested all four recipes, and BuzzFeed published the results on 12 November 2026.
Sources
- BuzzFeed — “I Tried 4 Celebrity Mashed Potato Recipes, And This One Is The Clear Winner”, by Micah Siva, 12 November 2026: buzzfeed.com/micahsiva/celebrity-mashed-potato-taste-test
- Martha Stewart — Perfect Mashed Potatoes: marthastewart.com/341854/perfect-mashed-potatoes
- Ina Garten — Garlic Mashed Potatoes: barefootcontessa.com/recipes/garlic-mashed-potatoes
- Food & Wine — Julia Child's Mashed Potatoes: foodandwine.com/julia-childs-mashed-potatoes-11839533
- Esquire — the recipe page linked for Snoop Dogg's Mayo Mash in the BuzzFeed test: esquire.com/food-drink/a25648144/best-mashed-potatoes-recipe
- Photo: “Mash Potatoes.jpg” by Jon Sullivan, Wikimedia Commons (public domain): commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Mash_Potatoes.jpg